Another day, another list of upcoming SFF adaptations that is a big, depressing sausage fest.
I feel like the common wisdom on the issue of diversity in media is that things are improving, but it’s very telling when just a quick count of the properties listed on this list of upcoming or possibly upcoming book-to-film/television adaptations shows forty based on work by men, but only five based on work by women. It probably goes without saying, but there are also only a couple of people of color on the list.
Moving on to the subjects of the projects, things are somewhat better, but not much. A full half of the projects focus on men’s stories, more if you count ensemble projects whose main characters are men. Only two projects are primarily about women. It’s a depressing toll, especially when we’d all like to believe that television and film are improving in diversity. If this list represents any improvement at all, it’s not good enough.
I don’t pretend to know exactly what would be good enough, but there are numerous books and comics that I think would improve the film and television landscape. Certainly, any of these would be significantly more interesting than another crop of shows starring square-jawed white dudes.
- The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet by Becky Chambers
Space opera has gotten popular again, and this one is very good. I’d love to see it as an ongoing television series, though that would require some expansion upon the source material. However, the novel itself is very episodic in nature, being told as a sequence of vignettes, each one focusing on a different character. This would lend itself well to being adapted as a miniseries or as a short series on a digital platform such as Netflix or Amazon, or it could be easily streamlined into a long film. The major downside of this book is that the high number of alien characters would require expensive special effects to produce, but the right production company could create something really wonderful if they were willing to spend the money on it.
- Lagoon by Nnedi Okorafor
This book just begs to be made into a big summer blockbuster a la Independence Day. I want to see it at the drive-in.
- Sorcerer to the Crown by Zen Cho
Like Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell, but more fun. Either film the book as it is for a delightful miniseries, or start where the book ends and continue the adventures of Prunella and Zacharias. Or both. Both would be good.
- God’s War by Kameron Hurley
While I’m not often a fan of just lifting characters from a book and writing all new stories around them for television, Kameron Hurley’s Beldame Apocrypha would be perfect for that treatment. Nyx is an amazing character of a type that doesn’t often get to be female, and her shifting crew of associates would make great fodder for a gritty sci-fi bounty hunter sort of thing. The world and characters Hurley created in this series are more than strong enough to carry a long-running television show, which would allow some of the bigger plots of the books to be explored at leisure.
- The Just City by Jo Walton
The goddess Athena gathers thinkers and dreamers from all ends of history in order to build Plato’s Republic. Apollo decides to become human so he can grow up as a child in the Just City. There are robots. And Socrates. And philosophical debates out the wazoo. I would watch this on TV, and I think I’m not the only one.
Obviously, I’m not saying no more square-jawed white dudes, ever, but all of these suggestions would make for a very nice change in the current landscape of entertainment. They would be even better if we could get more diversity behind the camera and in writing rooms for them as well.
The truth is that every time there are new surveys of the industry, it’s proven over and over again that the needle of diversity hasn’t moved much in thirty years. While there have been somewhat more actors of color in highly visible roles, it’s simply not true that things have really improved that much overall. The same can be said for the presence of women in cinema, and those who don’t fit neatly into the gender binary fare even worse.
Any (but preferably all) of the five works I suggest here would be a step in a better direction.
2 thoughts on “5 SFF Adaptations That Would Greatly Improve Genre Diversity in TV and Film”
I’ve only read THE JUST CITY on your list, and I agree by that alone! Since I read and liked that one, what book from this list do you recommend I read next?
If you really loved THE JUST CITY, the ones closest in tone to that would probably be SORCERER TO THE CROWN and THE LONG WAY TO A SMALL, ANGRY PLANET. However, LAGOON is amazing, and it’s definitely the one I’d recommend if you are trying to broaden your horizons. GOD’S WAR is brutal and dark and funny and heart wrenching; it’s like if a Tarantino film, Game of Thrones, and something well-written had a baby. Obviously, I highly recommend it, but it’s not for the faint of heart.
LikeLiked by 1 person